Their short jeans could have 24.5 inch inseam, or 27 inch inseam. Kaye: I wore them while walking around Washington, DC, which used to be a goddamn swamp, in 100-degree weather with 90% humidity. Do you have any specific ones you like from the Gap? I’d hate to think someone would buy these and accept their suckiness because they didn’t know other jeans exist. The Denim. I'm 20 years old, and previously, have been wearing Delia's jeans. Conz: I really like the material. I hate AE jeans now. Somebody mentioned Loft jeans, too, I think-- depending on the fit those may be a better option than AE or Old Navy, especially if you wait for a sale (loft seems to do 40% off pretty frequently). Browse men's jeans like skinny, Athletic, and slim, and women's jeans like Curvy, jegging, Mom and more! Prior to this, I had worn exclusively AE jeans for about 5-6 years, and all my pairs fit super well and lasted a long time. I bought 5 pairs of dark wash and it took me at LEAST 7 washings to get rid of the smell. Some people wore low-rise and everybody had different washes. this style flatters all body types) or a new white option to wear with your summery sandals, these are some of the best plus-size jeans on the market. In the end, here's how we thought all of the jeans stacked up: Ava & Viv Women’s Plus-Size Skinny Jeans, $29.99. Also try TJMaxx or Marshall's. Then I tried a pair of Levi's. Kaye: As they stretched out, they began to slide down my body — at which point the seam in the crotch started rubbing on my thighs. Conz: The fake pockets are just ridiculous. Kaye: We ordered the plus-size H&M jeans in a 20, a size bigger than I usually wear. Pretty close Imo. Gap and Old Navy have cheap and stylish clothes, but that cheap price tag comes from a company that has a loose and unethical approach to labor. Rachel: I was dreading putting these on and facing another week of shitty. If these are anything like the American Eagle extreme flex jeans, then I am sold. It’s a miracle! Hannah: By the second day, the zipper slid down without notice. How do Hollister jeans fit compared to American Eagle jeans?I usually wear a 6 in AE jeans. Gap's straight leg jeans will forever be my thigh bae. Our jeans collection includes the classics in baggy, boot cut and loose fit styles, so you're sure to find your preference here at Old Navy. In fact, Old Navy jeans are some of the worst quality I've ever had -- extremely comfortable though! Christina: A day after washing, they felt pretty loose around the hips. It also doesn't help that the Canadian dollar sucks now and they now cost $60-70 CAD instead of $40. They also seem to run smaller now, as I tried on an 8 in store (the same size my khaki pants are) and could barely get them on. 5.0 out of 5 stars 7. My advice is to go to each store and try on a pair that fits, and see how you feel about them! We hold major institutions accountable and expose wrongdoing. Kaye wore Ava & Viv Women’s Plus-Size Skinny Jeans, $29.99. Open menu to be able to find the possibility to enable the accessibility * There are lots of other brands out there that would have been great candidates for this test. I did AE for a while, but then I just got tired of buying a new pair every 6 months when they would inevitably rip in either my thigh or butt. So I stopped wearing jeans altogether for about 3-4 years, instead wearing khaki type pants in lots of colours. A quick comparison to other brands reveals the lack of size standardization across stores. This! The shirt is absolutely stunning it is fitted around my waist and is long enough to cover my stomach. Open menu to be able to find the possibility to enable the accessibility From Business: American Eagle in Bellingham, WA is a brand with expertly crafted, high quality jeans at our core. I used to religiously wear their jeans because even without my employee discount they were a great price for good quality. Link to aeo page. Hannah: If I’m being 100% honest, I checked myself out in the mirror every time I went to the bathroom. i would go one size up, so a 12. i own all twelves from old navy and my american eagle jeans are a 14. just to be sure though... american eagle has a … I wore them on my plane ride back to NY and this time around these were not comfy at all. Discover unique things to do, places to eat, and sights to see in the best destinations around the world with Bring Me! We know the importance of owning a durable jean that supports your needs and fits well with your style. Hey I noticed this as well but I realized they have two different style of jeans that look identical but feel very different! Old Navy Size Charts Measuring Tips. WHY ARE THESE PANTS FALLING OFF MY BODY. The only reason they’re not my favorite pair is that I had to alter them to make them work the way I wanted them to — I turned them into below-the-knee crops. Some people are different sizes in different brands, and sometimes the gaps in sizing are pretty astounding. Rachel: This is not what wearing clothes should feel like. I ordered these mom jeans on ae.com. Self care and ideas to help you live a healthier, happier life. I have a pair of their "modern skinny" jeans that has lasted me since 2013. California residents can opt out of "sales" of personal data. Most importantly, Americans need to fight the culture of fast fashion and buy less clothing and more of our wardrobe used. You can also find great deals in clearance (in store). The jean: Forever 21 Classic Skinny Jeans, $7.90*, and Forever 21 Plus-Size Classic Skinny Jeans, $12.90. To ensure a comfortable fit, … And they did not even fit over my thighs. *H&M changes their stock so often that the jeans currently available are slightly different than (although still pretty similar to) the exact jeans we tried. Definitely a lot less substantial than my old jeans, like half the thickness. For that price point, if you go to Nordstrom Rack, Neiman Last Call, or Saks Off Fifth you can eventually find some premium denim (AG, Joes's, J brand, Paige, etc.) Rachel: I could do that thing that they do in weight-loss ads to show how loose their jeans are. Amber. * Whenever we list a size in this post, that’s the size that the person tested from that brand. Each of us wore each pair of jeans for five days, for a total of five weeks of jeans-testing (and 24 pairs of jeans). Link to aerie page. ... american eagle jeans for women hollister jeans for men And Rachel and Hannah liked the fit, but not the wash and styling. I tried both on on the same day and came away thinking the old navy was the better value when on sale. Weirdly, I've had amazing luck with F21 jeans; I have a few pairs that I've been wearing and washing regularly for like 5 years. If you don't have a measuring tape, use a piece of string and hold it alongside a ruler. Even after a wash, they didn’t hold their tighter shape for long, or they tightened up too much. We tested 24 pairs of jeans from Old Navy, H&M, Forever 21, Target, and American Eagle to find out which brand's pants are actually worth the money. I've worked at both so i never buy anything full price...everything goes on sale frequently. They also didn’t carry 18 in the store by our office. Photos and design: Jon Premosch, Andrew Richard / BuzzFeed. WOMEN'S JEANS When you want women’s jeans that look fabulous, flatter your figure and don’t break the bank, you’ve gotta go to Old Navy. There's a noticeable difference between what they sell now and the denim quality even just a few years ago; it feels thinner, and wears out quickly, especially in the thighs. Kaye: American Eagle jeans stop at a size 18 that is too small to fit over my butt, so, uh, I didn’t test them. Except once you get them home, they stretch, and when you wash them, they shrink, and by the time you’ve worn them for a full week, they don’t look anything like the pair you tried on in the dressing room. H&M's online size chart only goes up to a size 16, anyway. They usually have the exact same colors in both styles. Waist. We create clothes that fit our customers lives, all made to take… 3. They fit well and are comfortable. Is this what wearing a burlap sack as penance for your sins is like? So then I realized that I had had a pair of thrifted Lucky jeans for like 5 or 6 years without wearing them out (until, of course, around the time that my Levi's were dying as well), so I just shelled out for a bogo 50% and bought two pairs to alternate between so they can "rest" a day between wears. For the issue of the inner thigh area wearing out (which is totally common and bound to happen eventually), try not to buy jeans with especially thin fabric and make sure they fit you well in the thigh area (neither too tight or too loose). Conz: One wash and there were little strings coming from the stitches. And once we had them in the office, they STILL didn't fit. Link to aeo page. I don't know what happened, but around 2012 AE took a "trendy" turn with their clothes and have started to ignore the quality their jeans used to have. : We had to order Kaye’s pair of Old Navy jeans online, because the stores around us in NYC didn’t have anything larger than a size 18 in stock.). Ok I need to check out a pair of these. Rachel: They started off being kinda tight and the crotch is looong. They didn’t chafe! American Eagle does not have a full petite clothing line, but their jeans do have short, regular and long and x-long inseams. Join the millions of fans who have discovered our bestselling women’s jeans – Rockstar Super Skinny Jeans. The waist inches listed here aren't based on the brands' size charts — we measured them both ourselves. The Gap uses a brand segmentation strategy to distinguish its three flagship brands, in order from high end to low end - Banana Republic, The Gap, and Old Navy. Link to aeo page. So we decided to solve the mystery once and for all: we each spent a week in five pairs of skinny jeans from Forever 21, H&M, Old Navy, American Eagle, and Target, and figured out which pairs were going to actually last. Another great option is ASOS! Click or tap to learn more about what fit well: But no pair of jeans is perfect. They run big, when I bought some american eagle jeans I was a size 5 and got a size 4 at the store they fit just fine. They feel like real denim, and look like real denim, and have pockets like real denim. If there's a difference in quality between the stores, I'd bet it's pretty small and varies greatly among each individual pair of jeans. Only one of us said she would buy and wear. All this to say, I was 100% all about AE pants. You try a pair on in the store, and they seem perfect! American Eagle is okay, their polos make me look like a guy, even at the right size. You may find many choices here, if you are looking for a pair of inexpensive pair of jean well under $100. I'd try on in store and then order. I’m going to swing by Old Navy the next time I need a new pair of jeans to try on the other styles, too. I'm only 5', and my Delia's jeans no longer fit me well, whether it's due to them stretching out or whatever. Link to aerie page. Depending on the style. Here are some tips to help you order the correct size. In addition to standard indigo shades, AEO offers denim pants, jackets and shirts in … American Eagle offers women's jeans from sizes 00 to 20, as seen in their sizing chart below. Link to aeo page. They are just, like, jean-shaped evil fabric swatches. I emptied an entire can of carpet cleaner, half a jug of detergent, and two jugs of white vinegar on a single pair of dark wash jeggings (the AEO sateen kind). 6 Answers. I have so many opinions!! Lately, Old Navy has shown more sales success than Gap. Click or tap to learn more about what really wasn't working: Conz’s jeans started falling apart, Hannah's zipper wouldn’t stay up, and Kaye's stretched to the point of sliding off. *Forever 21 changes their stock so often that the jeans currently on sale are slightly different than (although still pretty similar to) the actual jeans we tried. The material is thicker and holds up more in between washes. In all, it was roughly a 10 percent variance in … When I made the switch, all my khaki type pants were these from American Eagle and I love them. I liked them more as the week went on. Had to start wearing them to work before the smell finally started to dissipate. Very much "disposable" jeans you'll have to replace regularly. Kaye: I liked these a LOT. I have a GAP and an American Eagle both located conveniently close to me. There is an extra half-inch in the shoulders, longer sleeves, longer length in tops, lower waist position for tops and dresses, a nice longer rise, a full 36” inseam, and proper shaping to fit a woman’s figure. I feel like the quality is a lot better and there's a bigger range of fits and styles. The fit was on POINT. What kind of footwear do you wear with the pants that you've switched to? Abercrombie, which is dropping most of its logo business, is trying to “shift the customer base. 95. Can't speak to ae but I pefer Gap's denim over old navy. The jeans fit perfect, I bought the short ones and I am 5’2 they go to my ankles and stop at my feet, they fit around my waist with no gap in the back. After we washed them, the waist gave me a slight muffin top. Everything has become thin and stretchy. I've had them for 3 months now, wearing them very frequently (2-4 times a week), and they've held up great so far! Instead of shopping there, here is a few ideas of other American and ethical companies to buy from instead. Shop American Eagle Outfitters for men's and women's jeans, T's, shoes and more. We’re famous for our jeans not just for women but for the whole family. I know lots of others love AE, and I'm obviously not knocking that because I still get my skinny pants that aren't jeans there, but I really wasn't a fan of the Denim-X or whatever they're calling it at AE. 3. FREE Shipping. Levi's are on sale for around $40 right now at Macy's and Kohls, and are overall better quality than both ON and AE. I picked up a couple pairs at Old Navy earlier this year and they're holding up remarkably well, plus they seemed to have more non-distressed options (which is not something I thought I'd ever say). The denim goes on sale at least once every 2-3 months. They did not rip or get damaged while I was carrying huge metal things so…good quality! Christina: I already liked these a lot from trying them on initially, and the color’s great, too. Good luck! Or get some Levi's on sale at Macy's. They were not designed with the human body in mind. You should be able to get the rockstar denim at $22-24 ish. And, shockingly, I like how they look the most. Reporting on what you care about. The lure of great, affordable jeans is real: They're such an essential part of almost any person’s casual wardrobe. They too go 40% off on the regular. Oy. These jeans weren't my favorite I preferred my Old Navy Jeans so much better fitting. I love pants like those but I'm hesitant to buy them because.I'm not entirely sure what kind of shoes I should be wearing with them. All I could think of was my muffin top. But their downfall began on day two, when they started loosening up...significantly. Something for everyone interested in hair, makeup, style, and body positivity. I've been on the lookout for some durable jeans (I sadly always rip/wear out the inner thigh areas of my jeans) and am debating between American Eagle and Old Navy. So by default Old Navy is my favorite. Of the 31 women’s styles, which I consider to be an impressive selection, 5 are $29.50, 12 are $39.50 and 14 are $49.50. Hollister comes in odd sizes (3,5,7) Since she couldn't try them, we decided to compare the size 20 H&M jeans (on top) with Kaye’s own favorite size 18 pair from Torrid, a plus-size brand (beneath): The rest of us found pairs that fit, but mostly didn't like them overall. Just to put this out there in case people don't know: the "premium" denim you find at Nordstrom Rack etc. American Eagle: The bottom corner of the landing page says that AE jeans, including new washes, start at $29.50. I wanted to unbutton the top button buuuuuut my shirt wasn’t long enough to cover it, so I just sat there, trapped in my own jeans. Unless your local H&M actually carries plus sizes, it can take major guesswork to know what size you should order. They didn’t make me want to look in my closet for things to jazz them up with. Gap is better than Old Navy, but still stretch out and fade quickly. They do bag out a bit if I haven't washed them recently, which can be good or bad, but it's a preference thing. We just chose the ones that we felt were most available to most people in the US. Christina: They’re very boxy and thick, sort of restraining. Every Wednesday night (after three days of wearing them), we washed and dried the jeans according to the instructions on the tag. Christina: I went out in them the first night and they felt fine. 1. Crew were all 37 inches. Rachel: I immediately got complimented when I walked around in them the first day, and when I told the person they were from Forever 21, she was super surprised. 3.9 out of 5 stars 11. Not to mention, just about every kid that grew up in the US wore one of the Old Navy American flag t-shirts at least once. Then I went to buy a new pair of jeans when the urge struck me this past spring. Or is that more comfortable? Old Navy has produced Fashion Nirvana! It can also help not to wash them too often, and to wash inside out on delicate and hang dry. $40 for a pair of jeans, they're comfy and soft, they feel a lot sturdier than AE jeans do now. American Eagle runs a clearance sale during these months where you can get jeans for only $19.00 (regularly $59.95) — saving 68%. I felt like I was wearing a tight cardboard box. 95. Nothing says “you’re not welcome” like “stay home and order online.”. Cookies help us deliver our Services. If that week’s pair of jeans became unbearable (incredibly uncomfortable, begin to fall apart, etc), we could change into other clothing, but we had to be very specific about what made us hate them. I love the Haydens dearly, and it never digs into my waist or makes me feel like a sausage (which skinny jeans can do). From Business: American Eagle in Lynnwood, WA is a brand with expertly crafted, high quality jeans at our core. Rachel Christensen, Jon Premosch, Andrew Richard / BuzzFeed. In fact, Old Navy jeans are some of the worst quality I've ever had -- extremely comfortable though! $49.95 $ 49. Rachel: If I didn’t hate the pattern/decoration/fake folding marks on these jeans, I’d buy them forever. Hollister Women's Classic Stretch Low-Rise Super Skinny Jeans How-1. Michael Kors is a popular fashion brand that has leaned into logo-printed purses and … Old Navy measured 39.25 inches at the hip. I like a lot of their clothes, they just don't fit me well. Hannah: By the end of the third day, I could put my whole hand down the side of the jeans and have room between my hand and my hip. The material feels like tree bark. While size … uncomfortable jeans, but these are almost definitely just pajamas in disguise. American Eagle Outfitters for women The AEO women's collection is targeted at people who can't imagine living without jeans and use it in their stylizations to emphasize their character. A similar 2011 study by the New York Times found that even the three brands under the Gap umbrella - Gap, Banana Republic and Old Navy - have drastically different measurements. Same story. Levi’s, Express, Gap and J. Joe’s Jeans were the smallest hip measurement, at 36 inches, while American Eagle jeans were the biggest, at 39.75 inches. level 1 Kaye: Honestly, I frequently have bad experiences shopping at Old Navy in the store — nothing fits right, and they don’t often carry my size — so I was pretty surprised to find that I really like these jeans. So that's what I got, after my 5-6 month agonizing over American Eagle haha. All their jeans are now thin feeling and are more lycra or spandex than cotton. Christina: They don’t loosen up too much (so I still didn’t have quite enough butt room after a couple days of wear), but they’re pretty snug and nice. It makes the jeans feel so so cheap (which I know they are but, like, at least try?) Hollister Men's Skinny Jeans HOM-36. But it's still inevitable after a while of course! This is all obviously anecdotal; you might find you have a completely different experience. :) 0 1. 2. The jean: Christina, Conz, Hannah, and Rachel wore Mossimo Women’s Skinny Jeans, various styles, $27.99. They’d be good for summer because they’re thin. Everlane’s Curvy Jean is made with a mid-weight denim composed of 87% cotton, 12% polyester, and 1% elastane. They’re snug just the way I like them and they’re SHORT! But finding the right pair of jeans can sometimes feel like hunting for a diamond earring in a pile of old denim castoffs. I wear a size 8 (the same size I used to wear in AE jeans) and they have always fit me well and lasted a long time. FREE Shipping. I don’t think any other pair would’ve passed the barn test, tbh. So many things put this pair in the lead. Originally posted by idvsego View Post. Only time will tell how long they'll last, but they feel so sturdy in comparison to my old jeans. Conz: After washing, they were waaay tighter. Click or tap to learn more about what fit well (and what could have worked better): Everybody liked how comfortable they were on the first day. We create clothes that fit our customers lives, all made to… 3. Their jeans and jeggings are pretty good quality overall (they last me at least a year), but smell them before you leave the store - if there's even the slightest smell, it will get much worse after washing. Note: Some of these jeans were provided to us for review at no cost from the brands; others we purchased. These are the only pair that I never want to put on again. American Eagle Outfitters targets 15 years to 25 years old girls and offers trendy products. Search, watch, and cook every single Tasty recipe and video ever - all in one place! Conz: THE CROTCH IS TOO LOW. There are often outlet/discount-specific versions that are not as good as the standard versions. We bought H&M's plus-size jeans even though they cost seven times as much as the straight-size jeans we tried. * For this experiment, we chose to focus on a skinny cut because that's what stores sell the most of and one style almost every store carries, but mostly because they're just what we wear the most. There were a few things we didn’t love: Target's jeans came in a close second: Kaye picked them. Tell us why in the comments! * Have a different jean you love, or do you swear by one of our picks? The jeggings are the stretchy spandex feeling and the super skinny jeans are thicker with better quality. They do my butt zero favors, and the leg area (especially my thigh) was so loose. * Because we found people around the office and jeans from some of the most prevalent companies in the US, this pseudo-study definitely won't represent everyone who wears jeans. American Eagle Curvy Super Hi-Rise Jegging, Size 8, $49.95. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. American Eagle “has refocused on their core of denim and solid price and value,” Beder said. And then I discovered Old Navy. Measure around the narrowest part of your natural waist. I legit was loungin’, y’all. My shirt and jeans are both from American eagle. (Ed. 77 Kids line of product offerings are for the kids of ages 2-12 years with focus on 7 years to 12 years old … Hannah: They almost looked like harem pants. Old Navy Tall line is made specifically for women over 5’10”. Conz: I’m so happy these have REAL pockets. And the fabric is the comfiest. The sizing is laughable, and frankly, so is the $70 price tag, because the fabric on these jeans is definitely not soft or durable-feeling enough to justify that much goddamn money. on sale either online or in store. American Eagle Outfitters mom jeans first impressions and review. At $40, I have to agree with the other posters who are suggesting ON/Gap/AE/LOFT. and made it very easy to see where my undies ended. I've seen people talking on here about finding Old Navy jeans for around $20 and everyone seems to really love them, so it might be worth trying to find a great deal on those. In my experience, American Eagle is better quality than Old Navy. Hannah: These are not inspiring jeans. I used to love Gap denim but the last few I've purchased have quickly turned into a stretched out mess. They have such cute tanks and sweats and everything. All styles are available in additional sizes only at ae.com. The jean: H&M Skinny Regular Jeans, $19.99* (our pairs were $9.99), and H&M+ Shaping Skinny Jeans, $69.99. Right now denim is 40% off online including sale, putting them at around $40. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Rachel’s jeans had a strange streak on one leg that was extra noticeable after they were washed once. I'd hang them after so they'd air out then do it all over again. Old Navy's is a lot better than it used to be though. I worked at American Eagle for three years when I was in high school. Kaye: I really hated where they fell at my ankle and didn’t feel like they cuffed in a very stylish way. The jean: AEO Denim X Skinny Jean, $49.95 (but frequently available on special or sale — we got ours buy one, get one 50% off). We tested 24 pairs of jeans from Old Navy, H&M, Forever 21, Target, and American Eagle to find out which brand's pants are actually worth the money. Their jeans fit me too loosely, maybe that's just my body type though. Plus a try on. In my experience, American Eagle is better quality than Old Navy. Yes. I have a pair of Haydens and a pair of Lolitas, and I've never been happier with fit or comfort with a skinny jean with either of them. It's too bad because they do have tall / xs sizes which are super hard to find at an affordable price point. Although a couple of us thought they were pretty cozy. Shop Jeans for Men and Women at American Eagle to find your favorite styles. Whether you're in the market for a high-waisted boot-cut with tummy control, straight legs, skinny jeans, (yes! American Eagle. That being said, I do like my ON high rise rockstar jeans quite a bit. And at $70 a pop, that guesswork can get expensive. $44.95 $ 44. They super discount any online returns, washes they don't carry in store, etc. I think it will really come down to which store's jeans fit your body best and what sort of deals and sales are going on! I have multiple $12-15 pairs i've found. It was a little embarrassing to ask, and if I were a teen at whom this brand is actually aimed, it would be very embarrassing. Kaye: By the second day I was hauling them up often, and they don’t stay the same size for more than a day after washing. Anyone have any opinions, or is there another store I should try that is around this price point (~$40)? We were able to find one pair in everybody’s size at the Brooklyn Target, but it wasn’t the same jean for each person. American Eagle’s lightweight jegging is made with 90% cotton, 8% polyester, and 2% elastane. 6 years ago. Rachel: I only know these jeans suck because I’ve worn other jeans that don’t suck. On the second day, I took several naps in them; that’s how comfortable they were. They're jeans are super comfy and there are definitely some in your price range. Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!